County sale barnBarnBridge
Pro

Selling guide

Auction vs. private treaty for farm equipment

Private treaty means you set the price and deal with buyers yourself. At auction, bidders set the price on a fixed date. Each way has its place.

A plain comparison for farmers deciding how to sell machinery.

Private treaty: more money, more time

You set the asking price and negotiate. It usually brings the most money — an auction hammer price often lands 10 to 25 percent under a private asking price, partly because the buyer pays a premium on top.

The tradeoff is time: answering calls, showing the machine and handling tire kickers. It can take weeks or months.

Auction: a sale on a set date

An auction sells the machine on a known date, so you can plan around it. Bidding can push a clean, popular machine above what you'd ask. A reserve protects you from selling too cheap.

Auction buyers take equipment AS-IS, WHERE-IS, WITH ALL FAULTS, so good photos, hours and honest disclosure help bidders feel sure enough to bid.

Which to choose

Pick private treaty when you have time and want top dollar. Pick an auction when you want it gone on a date, when you're selling several machines, or when an unusual machine needs a wide pool of buyers.

See both numbers for your machine

Value your equipment

What are you pricing?
Make
Model
Engine horsepower

On the spec plate or in the model number — a 5075E is 75 HP.

Model year

Anything from 1950 to 2027.

Hours on the meter

Utility tractors run about 200 hours a year, so about 1,600 is normal at this age.

Condition

The honest middle. Most used machines land here.

What it has
State

Pick a state — freight and local demand move the number.

Estimated value

Example

This is a sample machine. Change any field to price yours.

$38,500 – $52,000

mid $45,000

Sell it yourself (asking range)
$38,500 – $52,000
Auction hammer range
$29,500 – $41,500

Hammer $35,500 → you net about $34,080 after the 4% seller fee ($75 min, $2,500 cap).

About what it cost new
$68,000

Estimate only. Built from typical new cost, a standard farm-equipment depreciation curve, hours vs expected hours for this class, condition, options, and brand residual. Not an appraisal, offer, or guarantee.

List this machine at $45,000Start an auction with reserve $29,500

What moved this number

  • 8 years oldWorth about 61% of the $68,000 it cost new
  • 1,500 hoursRight about average for its age (1,600 expected)
  • GoodThe baseline every other number is built on
  • 4WD / MFWD front assistAdds about 8%

On BarnBridge right now

Same class, nearby year and hours, from listings on this site. Outside dealer lots are not in this tape yet.

Common questions

Do you get more money at auction or selling privately?
Private sales usually bring more — auction hammer prices often run 10 to 25 percent under private asking prices. But auctions sell faster and on a set date.
What is private treaty?
Selling at a price you set and negotiate directly with a buyer, rather than taking bids at auction.
Can I set a minimum price at auction?
Yes. On BarnBridge equipment auctions, you can set a reserve so the machine doesn't sell below your number.
What are BarnBridge's auction fees?
Listing equipment on BarnBridge is free. Equipment auctions carry a 4% seller fee ($75 minimum) and a 5% buyer premium ($75 minimum), each capped at $2,500, and no subscription is required.

Keep reading

Try an auction or list it yourself

Listings are free. Equipment auctions carry a capped fee, and no subscription is required.

See equipment auctionsAll guides

Estimate only. Built from typical new cost, a standard farm-equipment depreciation curve, hours vs expected hours for this class, condition, options, and brand residual. Not an appraisal, offer, or guarantee.